Ballast Rock
  • Home
  • What We Do
    • Real Estate >
      • Multifamily
    • Ventures >
      • Acronym Venture Capital
      • Louisiana Green Fuels
    • Capital Advisory
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Leadership
  • Fund Updates
    • Acronym VC Funds
    • Louisiana Green Fuels
    • Sunbelt Fund III
    • Sunbelt Fund II
    • Sunbelt Fund I
  • Education
    • Portal "How To"
    • Corporate Deck
    • Articles
    • Press >
      • Lument Workforce Housing Webcast
      • CoStar Gleneagle Article
      • CoStar Coleman Article
      • Multifamily Executive
  • Login

Keep Up With Industry Trends

    ​Subscribe to our Newsletter
    First Name and Last Name
    Please provide your email
Subscribe

What’s on Real Estate Investors' Minds?

12/9/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture

Market Topics from Miami US Real Estate Conference for Latin American Investors

Last week Simon O'Shea (Ballast Rock CIO), Ian Garcia (Ballast Rock COO & Treasurer) and I were asked to present at a US Real Estate conference in Miami for Latin American Investors. Below are some of the topics on investors' minds at the conference:
  1. Capital continues to flow into real estate from both domestic as well as overseas investors. The swing to the far left in a number of South American nations has left local investors spooked and they are looking to move capital overseas and out of local currencies.  Some large local corporates have cleared out their cash holdings (examples in Chile), preferring to make sizable dividend payments to investors and allow those investors to move money offshore, rather than reinvest locally in the medium term.  A lot of this LatAm capital is looking for a home in US real estate.
  2. As cap rates have compressed nationally, people are getting more and more creative in their hunt for yield.  One developer was buying distressed/abandoned standalone golf courses and trying to develop new communities.  A potentially lucrative strategy, but also highly risky given the level of permitting risk involved.  Another developer was buying landfill to fill with asbestos and cement.  Not scalable (and questionable for the environment), but highly profitable.
  3. At the same time, investors are increasingly conscious of risk and looking for downside protection e.g. one sponsor is buying Midwest single family residential ("SFR") then converting to Section 8 housing - low upside, but protected downside trade (although they were scaling what appeared to be too quickly). 
  4. Net lease investments are also increasingly in demand as the economy rebounds and life returns to “sort of normal” – stable cashflows from high quality tenants on long term upwards only leases provides a downside limited investment with good protection against inflation in the future. 
  5. Prime Urban Office still remains relatively unloved.  It doesn’t feel like there’s a catalyst for forced/distressed sellers, but multiple owners discussed reducing their office footprint, not to zero, but by 1/3-2/3 as they move to hybrid office model.  Some discussion of "hub and spoke" office model, smaller central office, more suburban offices for staff/client meet-ups etc.
  6. Logistics was relatively popular topic, although consensus was that last mile was now too rich with a lot of capital deployed to new construction, meaning the pricing/supply dynamic doesn’t look favorable near term. Also concerns about tenant concentration risk (“everybody seems to be chasing Amazon”)
  7. Workforce multifamily was by far the most popular topic of conversation, and specifically value-add strategies in the Southeast - there is a lot of capital looking for deals here (it was a SE conference, so naturally some geographical bias). But we expect cap rate compression to continue as there is so much capital looking for not enough product. 

Inflation on Everyone's Minds

There were a variety of views on inflation and lots of discussion about high appliance prices, difficulty in getting windows/trusses for construction etc. and Insurance costs have also gone up across the board. Whether inflation is/will be transitory is debatable, but the consensus was that most property classes should perform well in an inflationary environment. 
​
In particular, workforce multifamily should perform well in periods of higher than normal inflation as the short- term nature of our leases allows us to react quickly to inflationary pressures, and the relatively low price points for the average rental rates on our portfolio mean that wage inflation should more than adequately offsets any rent increases for our communities. 
​
Picture

Concerns over Cap Rate Movement

Given the current absolute levels of cap rates, there was a lot of discussion about the possibility of cap rates increasing.  Again, there were a variety of views, but we believe that our strategy of workforce multifamily value-add provides an effective hedge against any reasonable future cap rate increases. We only purchase assets where we believe we’ve identified significant net operating income upside from our capacity to add value and can look to push cap rates 100-150bps higher through operational efficiencies and CapEx deployment. 

At Ballast Rock we help originate and distribute countercyclical and recession resilient real estate funds.  Please feel free to connect to learn more about how we work with experienced real estate professionals to offer investors the opportunity to invest in income producing assets with a positive social impact.​
Contact Us
0 Comments

Why Invest in Real Estate in Small- to Medium-Sized Cities?

12/4/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
​At Ballast Rock, we specialize in investing in real estate in small- to medium-sized cities across the Southeastern USA because our experience shows properties in these cities often offer better opportunities to add value (i.e. “alpha”) and increasingly more significant market rent growth potential in the current market environment.  As demonstrated in the graphs below, we have been able to outperform our own underwriting on our current portfolio both in terms of cap-rate and rent growth because - in our experience - the demand/supply constraints in real estate are often particularly acute in smaller markets compared to primary markets.  In this article we will highlight some of the quantitative data that explain our investment thesis and provide some qualitative reasoning for this opportunity.
Picture
These two graphs were built using Ballast Rock internal data, comparing our expectations with the realized performance over two years since acquisition for all assets in Sunbelt Fund I and Sunbelt Multifamily Fund II thus far.
Picture

Quantitative Data:

​Costar (one of the main real estate industry data providers) has sales indexes that track two segments: 
i) “value-weighted,” meaning big sales in the largest markets, and,
ii) “equal-weighted,” made up of more numerous but lower-priced sales in smaller areas.  
Both moved higher in October, but the equal-weighted U.S. composite index advanced at a stronger pace:
Picture
Source: Costar
​The above data demonstrates that pricing of smaller deals in smaller markets has outpaced larger deals in larger markets since the onset of the pandemic.  Given the above, we wanted to provide some qualitative rationale as to why we believe we are able to add more value add in smaller markets compared to larger markets.

Qualitative Reasons:

‘Mom-and-Pop’ Owners:
Some of our success stories (Huntingdon, Holiday Cove, Spring Lake, Amelia West) have come when buying properties that are owned by ‘mom and pop’ owners.  Whether it is a single real estate owner/operator, a couple that is managing their nest egg, or a family that has owned the property for years, there are frequently immediate avenues for upside when buying from these types of sellers.
​
To provide a concrete example we can look at Huntingdon in Albany, GA. The prior owner was a family that had owned the property for 30+ years. The below bullet points highlight the types of mismanagement that we frequently see when buying from mom-and-pop sellers:
  • They were running improvements and typical capex spending above the line which resulted in $2.5-3k/unit/year in above-the-line repairs & maintenance cost. Our typical expectation for an asset of this vintage is $600-900/unit/year in repairs & maintenance cost.
  • One of the family members was spending tens of thousands on custom cabinetry for apartments that rent for $600-800 in Albany, GA where a new basic set of cabinetry is available (at a cost of $3-4k/unit) and would return the same rental premium.
  • They were paying all 3 of themselves salaries through the community, resulting in a total of six staff members for a community that would typically run 2-3 staff.
Picture
Fayetteville, NC is an example of a city in which Ballast Rock invests.
Less Competition from Other Buyers: 
In our experience, there is a smaller buyer pool in secondary/tertiary markets than in primary markets. Because of this smaller buyer pool, we see fewer bidding wars during fully marketed processes, and we are frequently able to acquire assets at a discount relative to the cap rates at which similar vintage/sized properties would have traded in primary markets (based on CoStar data).
No Daily Pricing Software for Rents:
In larger urban markets with more competition, many larger operators tend to use daily pricing software to set their rental levels.  This daily pricing software tracks the rental levels of other comparable properties and will frequently undercut prices in order to better generate demand for properties.  In smaller markets without daily pricing software, we can manually set our rents on a monthly or bi-monthly basis without having to worry about daily/weekly shifts in rental levels.
Picture
Columbia, SC is another example of a city in which Ballast Rock invests.
Brokers Not Maximizing Sale Proceeds:
Typically, price per unit (and total deal size) in secondary/tertiary markets trails that of primary markets according to Costar data. As a result, there are fewer brokers competing for business and listing agreements in these markets. Because of the reduced competition, we have found that brokers will fall short on pricing for a variety of reasons:
  • Inexperience: the brokers that work these smaller deals are generally the junior members of their team. This lack of experience frequently manifests itself in a lack of attention to detail on underwriting.  Whether the broker misses an avenue to add ancillary revenue or an expense line item that is due to be cut, this inexperience can result in incorrectly priced underwriting.
  • Resource management: because of the lower fee sums for smaller deals, brokerage shops will often allocate fewer internal resources to the sales of these assets. 
  • Smaller brokerage shops: because of the competition in primary markets, we have found that a lot of smaller brokerage shops target smaller markets in order to have a better shot at securing listings.  These smaller shops frequently do not have the same mailing list of the larger shops, which results in fewer eyes on any given deal. 
At Ballast Rock we help originate and distribute countercyclical and recession resilient real estate funds.  Please feel free to connect to learn more about how we work with experienced real estate professionals to offer investors the opportunity to invest in income producing assets with a positive social impact.
Let's Connect
0 Comments

    Authors:
    ​Tom Carroll

    Tom is the Founder and CEO of Ballast Rock. 
    ​Prior to becoming a private equity professional, Tom had a 14yr career on Wall Street, most recently as a desk head at Goldman Sachs & Co.

    Picture

    ​Simon O'Shea
    ​
    As Chief Investment Officer for Ballast Rock Simon leverages his almost twenty years working in a variety of Institutional Fixed Income sales management positions for companies like Morgan Stanley, Lloyds Bank and BNP Paribas. 

    Picture

    Categories

    All
    Industry Trends
    Market Trends
    Portfolio Strategies

    Archives

    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    September 2020
    March 2020
    November 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019

    Press
    • Multifamily Executive
    Relevant Readings
    • Sunbelt Shines: 2019 Census Data​​
    • Small Southern Cities​
    • ​Rise of the Sunbelt
    • Rent Control
    • Movement from Big 3
    • Metros
    • Rising Rents in Affordable Cities​​
Company
What We Do
​Real Estate
Ventures
Capital Advisory

Leadership
Fund Updates

​
Resources
Updates
​
Articles
​Corporate Deck
​Business Continuity Plan 

Important Disclosures
Social
LinkedIn
Contact
Submit

The information contained on the Ballastrock.com web site has been prepared by Ballast Rock Holdings LLC (“Ballast Rock”) without reference to any particular user’s investment requirements or financial situation. Potential investors are encouraged to consult with professional tax, legal, and financial advisors before making any investment into a private offering of securities.  An investment in private securities would be speculative and would involve a high degree of risk. Investors must be prepared to bear the economic risk of such an investment for an indefinite period of time and be able to withstand a total loss of their investment. Please consider carefully the investment objectives, risks, transaction costs, and other expenses related to an investment prior to deciding to invest.  All private placements of securities and other broker dealer activities are currently offered through a partnership with Independent Brokerage Solutions LLC MEMBER: FINRA / SIPC (“IndieBrokers”), which is located at 485 Madison Avenue 15th Floor New York, NY 10022. (212) 751-4424. Ballast Rock Holdings LLC and its affiliates are independent and unaffiliated with IndieBrokers.  Any securities transactions or related activities offered by Ballast Rock associated persons are conducted in their capacities as registered representatives of IndieBrokers.  Please see our Form CRS. 
Picture
To check the background of IndieBrokers and its representatives, visit FINRA’s BrokerCheck. 
Read more.
© 2022 Ballast Rock Holdings LLC. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • What We Do
    • Real Estate >
      • Multifamily
    • Ventures >
      • Acronym Venture Capital
      • Louisiana Green Fuels
    • Capital Advisory
  • About Us
    • Our Story
    • Leadership
  • Fund Updates
    • Acronym VC Funds
    • Louisiana Green Fuels
    • Sunbelt Fund III
    • Sunbelt Fund II
    • Sunbelt Fund I
  • Education
    • Portal "How To"
    • Corporate Deck
    • Articles
    • Press >
      • Lument Workforce Housing Webcast
      • CoStar Gleneagle Article
      • CoStar Coleman Article
      • Multifamily Executive
  • Login